EU investigates airline ticket selling websites. Questions and answers
European Commission - MEMO/07/459 14/11/2007
Brussels, 14 November 2007
What is a Sweep?
An "EU - sweep" is a joint EU enforcement action to check for compliance with consumer protection laws.
The first such sweep exercise was carried out to check websites selling airline tickets. It was carried out by the Member States' enforcement authorities (the Consumer Protection Enforcement Network – CPC, which came into being at the end of 2006) and was co-ordinated by the European Commission. There are more sweep actions scheduled for 2008.
Authorities from 15 Member States and Norway participated in this first joint exercise. Participation was on a voluntary basis. 447 sites were checked for misleading or deceptive messages and/or information, of which 226 were flagged as in some way not respecting consumer protection law. 63 were cross border cases and were flagged for follow up action through the CPC network by co-operation between national authorities in different EU member states. The rest will be followed up at national level.
The focus of this EU sweep exercise is not information or fact finding but to obtain enforcement. Because consumer rights are no good if they're just on paper, they have to be enforced. This is a whole new way of doing business to boost consumer rights.
When did it take place?
Enforcement authorities examined sites during the week of 24-28 September.
Why did you pick airline ticket websites for the first sweep action?
Because airline ticket and passenger complaints are one of the leading areas for complaints coming into the European Consumer Centres (ECC). The ECC-Net is an EU wide network that provides information on cross border shopping to consumers, ensures that they are aware of their rights and gives support in the event of a complaint.
How big is this market
EU Airline travel is a market of 700 million passengers per year. This includes internal and external travel (external being where an EU citizen travels beyond the EU) and it is a highly digitalised market.
How does an enforcement "sweep" work in practice?
There are two steps:
What sanctions can be taken?
EU consumer laws are enforced – and sanctions and penalties are therefore set – at national level. Possible measures can include a request to a company demanding to change or cease a prevailing practice, imposing and collecting fines, or closing down web-sites. Enforcement authorities are obliged to take measures (repeatedly if need be) until the infringement has ceased.
The Member states involved
Which Member States participated in the exercise?
The following Member States took part in the sweep exercise: Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Cyprus, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Greece, Italy, Lithuania, Malta, Portugal, Spain, Sweden. Norway also participated. The full list of participating authorities which are all part of the CPC Network (Consumer Protection Co-operation Network) is attached.
Which Member States did not participate and why?
This is the first consumer enforcement sweep and all Member States were very supportive of the exercise. While it was not possible – due to resource, timing or other constraints - for all MS to participate on this occasion it does not mean they were not keen to do so and they will most probably participle in future exercises.
Why does this sweep need to be done with EU co-operation?
It is obvious that deceptive online selling practices often concern operators located in different countries and they can more effectively be tackled with the kind of EU wide co-operation which has been established in the framework of the Consumer Protection Cooperation Regulation. A website selling to one member state e.g. France may well be based in Belgium. To get the illegal practice corrected France needs to request the co-operation of the Belgian authorities.
What about the international dimension. What about airlines operating from outside the EU and how do we deal with those countries?
This issue is complex. When companies from outside the EU advertise inside the EU, then EU laws apply. However, enforcement is difficult. For contract terms, the situation is far more complex and the applicable law depends on a number of factors and interlinks with international conventions.
However, we are already exploring options to cooperate with the US authorities in the area of consumer protection, notably via the Enforcement Network, and plan to expand these discussions to other partners.
Can ICPEN help in such concrete international cases?
ICPEN stands for International Consumer Protection and Enforcement Network. There are 36 members including 24 EU Member States. It is an international organisation of enforcement authorities that is mainly a forum for exchange of information and best practice. Members also participate in case handling which could include exchange of information in international cases. They also conduct sweeps as part of their activities.
Some ICPEN member countries also carried out a sweep in the same week of September. That sweep focused on websites which use testimonials, guarantees and/or endorsements for misleading purposes, for example, sweepers searched for, among others, cures for major illnesses such as cancer and AIDS.
The EU laws
What are the EU consumer rules that airline companies need to comply with?
The Consumer Acquis and its translation into national laws are relevant here. In particular the CPC Regulation (EC) 2006/2004 on consumer protection co-operation, which set up the new enforcement framework, the Council Directive 84/450/EEC on misleading advertising and the Council Directive 93/13/EEC on unfair terms in consumer contracts.
Why did you focus on misleading selling practices and unfair contract terms only?
The sweep targeted key problem areas - misleading information and unfair contractual terms – these are very common problems encountered by consumers when they try to buy something on-line.
What kinds of practices are misleading? Can you give practical examples of practices that are not allowed for sites selling airline tickets?
Can you give some examples of unfair contract terms?
Can you tell us about the new legislation from DG Transport which is in the pipeline?
Yes, it is the Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on common rules for the operation of air transport services in the Community (COM (2006) 396), the so called "Third Package in Air Transport.
The Regulation will further clarify that the final price includes all applicable fares, charges, surcharges, taxes and fees which are unavoidable and foreseeable at the time they are published. These rules will also apply to fares and rates published on the Internet. It will apply to all flights within the EU and to flights of all companies departing from an EU airport.
Which articles of the package apply to the subject of the airline ticket sweep?
The provisions on pricing are included in Chapter 4 of the proposed Regulation. The Commission proposal is currently being discussed by the European Parliament and the Council and we hope that an agreement will be reached in the second reading.
226 sites were found to have irregularities of one or several of the kind described above. They are further detailed in the Press Release.
Which airlines and companies?
In four months, once the majority of cases will have been dealt with by the authorities, the Commission intends to publish a list of companies concerned. The company names are known to the national enforcement authorities which are now following up at national level and cross border issues for specific companies will be dealt with through the EU enforcement network.
Did the results demonstrate a cross-border dimension? How significant was it?
Yes. 63 cases were cross border in nature. It was 27.8% of all infringements.
Were breaches different in different Member States?
Were the same companies checked by different MS and how does this impact on the results?
Some airlines companies obviously operate in several countries as well as booking operators. However, they usually have different sites for different markets and breaches may be found in one language version and not in another. So the result reflects the numerous sites which are concerned.
What will the next sweeps focus on?
Obviously, sweeps will always be kept secret until after the preliminary "sweep" investigation has been carried out to maximise their effectiveness. The Commission is currently consulting with Member State consumer authorities on the priority issues for next sweeps programmed for 2008 – to deliver maximum benefit for consumers and the market.
Annex: 'EU – Sweep' – Airline ticket selling websites
Contact details of participating enforcement authorities